West Lake Hills and Barton Creek sit only a few miles apart on Austin's west side, and buyers often tour both in the same weekend. They feel very different. West Lake Hills is a small, independent city of wooded streets and individually built homes. Barton Creek is a collection of gated sections wrapped around a country club and resort. I sell in both, and this is the comparison I give buyers deciding between them.
The short version
- Choose West Lake Hills for a close-in address, its own city government, mature trees, and Eanes ISD across the entire city.
- Choose Barton Creek for gated sections, golf and club life, and newer homes on larger Hill Country lots.
- School zoning is the biggest practical difference: all of West Lake Hills is in Eanes ISD, while most of Barton Creek is in Austin ISD, with the Barton Creek West section in Eanes ISD.
In this guide
1. At a glance
Factor | West Lake Hills | Barton Creek |
|---|---|---|
What it is | An incorporated city of 3,444 residents, about 3.6 square miles | More than a dozen gated sections around a country club and resort |
Location | West of MoPac, ten to fifteen minutes from downtown | Southwest of downtown, in the Hill Country off Loop 360 and Bee Cave Road |
Gates | Mostly open streets, with a few gated enclaves | Gated sections throughout |
Schools | Eanes ISD citywide | Mostly Austin ISD; Barton Creek West in Eanes ISD |
Signature amenity | Mature oaks, views, and proximity to downtown | Four golf courses, the Barton Creek Country Club, and the Omni resort |
2. Setting and character
West Lake Hills grew street by street, so neighbors' homes range from original ranch houses to new contemporary estates. Heritage oaks, winding roads, and hillside views define the setting, and the city's own zoning and tree rules protect that character. My Living in Westlake guide covers daily life there.
Barton Creek was planned around golf. Its gated sections each have their own HOA, architecture, and feel, from golf-course villas and townhomes to custom estates on an acre or more in sections such as the Estates of Barton Creek and the Woods of Barton Creek. The four courses include two designed by Tom Fazio, one by Ben Crenshaw and Bill Coore, and one by Arnold Palmer.
3. Homes and prices
Measure | West Lake Hills area (78746) | Barton Creek |
|---|---|---|
Median sale price | $2.10 million (12 months to November 2026) | About $2.8 million on roughly 30 MLS closed sales (12 months to November 2026) |
Other benchmark | $649 per square foot median for homes from $2 million to $10 million | Zillow Home Value Index of $2.3 million, up 5.5% (August 2026) |
Typical housing | Custom homes from original ranches to new contemporary estates | Villas and townhomes near the courses, custom estates in the larger sections |
The 78746 figures cover a much larger and more varied market than West Lake Hills alone, and Barton Creek's median rests on a small number of sales, so I price every home against its own section or street. Recent sales of mine show the range: 1704 Mount Larson in Westlake sold for $5,575,000 on 1.01 acres, and in Barton Creek I have sold a modern estate on Mendocino Drive designed by Jay Corder, AIA, and a 1.13-acre estate in the Woods of Barton Creek.
4. Schools and jurisdiction
West Lake Hills is the only city located entirely within Eanes ISD, which holds an A rating from the Texas Education Agency. In Barton Creek, school zoning changes by section: most sections are in Austin ISD, while Barton Creek West is zoned to Eanes ISD. Assignments are set by address, so I confirm them for every home.
Jurisdiction differs too. West Lake Hills sets its own zoning, permits, and city tax rate. Barton Creek sections fall under the City of Austin or Travis County depending on location, with HOAs adding their own design rules and dues. My Barton Creek homes for sale page and Eanes ISD homes for sale page break this down further.
5. Lifestyle: club life vs a small city
- Barton Creek: life centers on the Barton Creek Country Club and the Omni Barton Creek resort, with golf, tennis, dining, and a spa inside the community. Club membership is separate from home ownership, so ask about membership categories and waitlists early.
- West Lake Hills: life centers on the neighborhood itself and quick access to the rest of Austin: Westlake's shops and restaurants, Lake Austin, Zilker Park, and downtown, all within minutes.
6. Which one fits you
If you want | Look first at |
|---|---|
Eanes ISD without checking section by section | West Lake Hills |
The shortest drive to downtown | West Lake Hills |
Gated living and an on-site club | Barton Creek |
Golf out your back door | Barton Creek |
An established street of individually built homes | West Lake Hills |
A newer custom estate on an acre or more | Both, in the right section or street |
Insider note: in both places, many of the best homes sell before they reach the public sites. Barton Creek sections and West Lake Hills streets each have their own buyer pools, and knowing who is thinking about selling matters as much as watching new listings.
Frequently asked questions
Is Barton Creek in Eanes ISD?
Mostly no. Most Barton Creek sections are zoned to Austin ISD, while the Barton Creek West section is zoned to Eanes ISD. Confirm the assignment for each address.
Is West Lake Hills or Barton Creek more expensive?
Barton Creek's median was about $2.8 million on roughly 30 MLS closed sales in the 12 months to November 2026, compared with $2.10 million across the 78746 ZIP code that includes West Lake Hills. Prices in both vary widely by section and street.
Is Barton Creek gated?
Yes. Barton Creek is made up of more than a dozen gated sections, each with its own HOA, while most West Lake Hills streets are open.
Which is closer to downtown Austin?
West Lake Hills, which sits just west of MoPac, ten to fifteen minutes from downtown. Barton Creek is farther southwest in the Hill Country.
Do you have to join the club to live in Barton Creek?
No. Club membership is separate from home ownership. Ask the club about membership categories before you buy if golf or club access matters to you.
Deciding between West Lake Hills and Barton Creek?
I can tour both with you in a day and show you homes in each that are not on the market yet. Start a conversation.
Sources: U.S. Census 2020 via Wikipedia (West Lake Hills); Eanes ISD boundaries via Wikipedia; Texas Education Agency accountability ratings; Keenan Group 12-month MLS data for 78746 (through November 11, 2026); Zillow Home Value Index for Barton Creek (August 31, 2026); local brokerage MLS reports for Barton Creek (November 2026); Darin Walker notable transactions.