What $5 Million Buys in Westlake vs Tarrytown

What $5 Million Buys in Westlake vs Tarrytown

Buyers in the $5 million range ask me the same two questions almost every week: Westlake or Tarrytown, and how much house does that budget really buy? Both neighborhoods sit minutes from downtown Austin, both are tightly held, and both carry a real premium. But $5 million buys a very different property on each side of Lake Austin. I have lived in West Lake Hills for more than 50 years and closed several Westlake-area sales right around this price, so here is the side-by-side I give my own clients.

The short version

  • In Westlake, $5 million buys a newer home of roughly 4,500 to 4,800 square feet on a lot of about half an acre to an acre, often with a pool and views.
  • In Tarrytown, $5 million sits near the top of the market and buys a new or fully rebuilt home of roughly 3,500 to 4,500 square feet on a quarter-acre in-town lot.
  • Westlake gives you more land and more house. Tarrytown gives you the closer-in address. Schools, city limits, and taxes differ on each side, so they belong in the decision from day one.

In this guide

  1. The numbers behind each market
  2. What $5 million buys in Westlake
  3. What $5 million buys in Tarrytown
  4. Land: acres versus lots
  5. Schools, cities, and taxes
  6. Daily life and the commute
  7. Lake Austin, the waterfront wildcard
  8. Westlake vs Tarrytown at $5 million
  9. Frequently asked questions

1. The numbers behind each market

Both markets trade well above the Austin average, and both are priced by the square foot and the lot far more than by bedroom count. Here is how they compared over the past 12 months of MLS closed sales of single-family homes.

Measure

Westlake (78746)

Tarrytown

Median sale price

$2.10 million

$1.83 million

Median price per square foot, all homes

$585

$626

Median price per square foot, $2M to $10M homes

$649

$758

Single-family homes sold

256

84

Two things stand out. Tarrytown costs more per square foot, which is the price of being in town. And Westlake sells roughly three times as many homes a year, because it covers far more ground, which gives a $5 million buyer more choices at any given moment.

2. What $5 million buys in Westlake

Modern hilltop home at 1704 Mount Larson in Westlake with downtown Austin skyline views at dusk

At $5 million in Westlake, you are in the upper tier of the market without reaching the lakefront and large view estates that trade well into eight figures. My own recent sales show exactly what this budget buys:

  • 1704 Mount Larson, $5,575,000: a 2010 modern home at the top of Westlake with 4,780 square feet, three bedrooms, a pool, and downtown skyline views on 1.01 acres.
  • 308 Reveille Road, $4,995,000: a 2017 warm contemporary with five bedrooms on a tree-filled 0.44-acre lot, with a heated pool and spa, a full summer kitchen, and a bocce court, two minutes from the shops on Bee Cave Road.
  • 300 Inwood Road, Rollingwood, $5,500,000: a remodeled five-bedroom home with 4,457 square feet on 0.58 acres, where I represented the buyer.

The pattern is consistent: a newer or extensively updated home of about 4,500 to 4,800 square feet, a lot of roughly half an acre to an acre, resort-style outdoor living, and on the right street, a view. What you give up is walkability. Westlake is a driving neighborhood of winding roads and hills, and for most of my Westlake clients that privacy is the point.

Covered terrace overlooking the heated pool at 308 Reveille Road in Westlake

3. What $5 million buys in Tarrytown

Aerial view of Tarrytown's tree canopy with the downtown Austin skyline beyond

In Tarrytown, $5 million sits near the top of the market. The neighborhood's median sale price is $1.83 million, and new construction typically runs from about $3 million to $6 million and up, driven by the cost of the land. New and rebuilt homes command well over $1,000 per square foot. A 4,744-square-foot newer home on Timberwood Circle, for example, was listed at $6.5 million, about $1,370 per square foot.

At those prices, $5 million in Tarrytown buys:

  • A new or fully rebuilt home of roughly 3,500 to 4,500 square feet, or a larger renovated original
  • A standard in-town lot, commonly 75 by 150 feet or larger, about 0.2 to 0.3 acres
  • Modern finishes and a pool where the lot allows
  • A five-minute drive to Lake Austin, Red Bud Isle, and Walsh Boat Landing

What you gain is location. Tarrytown runs roughly from Windsor Road to Lake Austin Boulevard, between Exposition Boulevard and the Lake Austin shoreline. It has sidewalks, a mature oak canopy, and a mix of 1930s Tudor Revival and Craftsman originals, mid-century ranches, and contemporary new builds.

4. Land: acres versus lots

Land is the single biggest difference between the two markets, and it is where most of the $5 million goes. In Westlake, the same budget buys two to four times the land it buys in Tarrytown. But the hills, heritage oaks, septic systems, and impervious cover limits decide how much of a Westlake lot you can actually use. I explain how that plays out in why two Westlake lots the same size sell for very different prices.

Tarrytown lots are smaller and flatter, so more of the budget goes into the house itself. Tarrytown is also inside the City of Austin, where the HOME code changes now allow up to three homes on many single-family lots and smaller minimum lot sizes. Before you buy there, look at what could be built on the lots around you, not just your own.

5. Schools, cities, and taxes

Most of Westlake is served by Eanes ISD, which holds an A rating from the Texas Education Agency, and much of it falls under the City of West Lake Hills, the City of Rollingwood, or Travis County rather than the City of Austin. Our Eanes ISD homes for sale page covers the district in detail.

Tarrytown is in Austin ISD and is zoned to Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle School, and Austin High School, with the Liberal Arts and Science Academy as a magnet option. It sits inside the City of Austin, so permitting, city services, and the city portion of the tax bill all follow Austin rules.

On a $5 million home, the full tax rate stack of city, school district, and county adds up to a meaningful annual difference, so I run it for every address a client is serious about. School assignments are set by address, and I confirm those for every home as well.

6. Daily life and the commute

Tarrytown is the closer of the two. Downtown is about ten minutes away, and Lake Austin Boulevard puts coffee, dining, and the lake within a short drive or bike ride. It is an in-town lifestyle with an established neighborhood feel.

Westlake is ten to fifteen minutes from downtown via Loop 360, MoPac, or Bee Cave Road. In exchange, you get space, quiet, and the Hill Country at your door, with Westlake's shopping and restaurants close by. My West Lake Hills neighborhood guide covers daily life there in more detail.

7. Lake Austin, the waterfront wildcard

Both neighborhoods touch Lake Austin, and waterfront changes the math completely. On either shore, true waterfront starts around $5 million and climbs quickly. Frontage, water depth, dock rights, and the grade to the water drive value far more than square footage. If the lake is on your list, start with our Lake Austin homes for sale page.

8. Westlake vs Tarrytown at $5 million

Consideration

Westlake

Tarrytown

Home size

About 4,500 to 4,800 sq ft

About 3,500 to 4,500 sq ft new

Lot

About 0.4 to 1 acre, often sloped

About 0.2 to 0.3 acres, mostly flat

Views

Common, depending on elevation

Rare, a premium when present

Schools

Eanes ISD

Austin ISD

City

Mostly West Lake Hills, Rollingwood, or county

City of Austin

Walkability

Low, a driving neighborhood

Higher, with sidewalks and in-town streets

Best fit

Buyers who want space, privacy, and views

Buyers who want an in-town address close to downtown

Insider note: at $5 million, some of the best homes on both sides of the lake never reach the public market. Sellers at this level often prefer a quiet sale, and builders pre-sell their best projects. I hear about these homes first, and I can tell you quickly whether a property is priced right for its street.

Frequently asked questions

Is Westlake or Tarrytown more expensive?

Westlake has the higher median sale price, $2.10 million versus $1.83 million in Tarrytown over the past 12 months. Tarrytown costs more per square foot, so the same budget buys a smaller home on a smaller lot in Tarrytown.

How big a home does $5 million buy in Westlake?

About 4,500 to 4,800 square feet of newer or updated home on roughly half an acre to an acre. Recent examples include 1704 Mount Larson at $5,575,000 with 4,780 square feet on 1.01 acres.

How big a home does $5 million buy in Tarrytown?

About 3,500 to 4,500 square feet of new or fully rebuilt home on a lot of roughly 0.2 to 0.3 acres. New Tarrytown construction commands well over $1,000 per square foot.

What school districts serve Westlake and Tarrytown?

Most of Westlake is in Eanes ISD. Tarrytown is in Austin ISD and is zoned to Casis Elementary, O. Henry Middle School, and Austin High School. Assignments are set by address.

Does $5 million buy a Lake Austin waterfront home?

Lake Austin waterfront starts around $5 million and climbs quickly, so $5 million is entry level. Frontage, water depth, and dock rights drive the price more than the size of the home.

Deciding between Westlake and Tarrytown?

I know both sides of the lake street by street, and I can show you what $5 million buys today, including homes that are not on the market yet. Start a conversation.

Sources: Keenan Group Luxury Market Index, 12-month MLS closed single-family sales for 78746 (through November 11, 2026) and Tarrytown (through November 19, 2026); Fenton Grossman Group, Tarrytown new construction pricing (mid-2026); Redfin listing data (September 2026); Texas Education Agency accountability ratings; Darin Walker notable transactions.

Work With